Skip to content

Could we be anywhere else on softwood?

I’m somewhat aghast and astounded that a good portion of the media and politicians in this country seem to be surprised at this week’s announcement of U.S. countervailing duties on softwood lumber.

Bill Phillips

Watching some of the newscasts and reading some of the newspapers it’s easy to get the impression that this came out of the blue. It didn’t, of course. It’s been brewing for some time and the date for the announcement of tariffs was set in January. Yet, a whole bunch of people in this country who knew, or at least should have known, are now feigning surprise. That doesn’t help us at all.

In addition, there’s enough finger pointing going on to keep us going for some time.

Give Cariboo-Prince George MP Todd Doherty credit for not being one of the surprised ones. This has been on his agenda from Day One. The Conservatives, however, are pointing to Prime Minister Justin Trudeau’s inaction on the file. While that may be true, the current agreement expired under his predecessor, Conservative Stephen Harper’s watch.

BC NDP leader John Horgan has pointed the finger at Liberal leader Christy Clark for not being more vocal on the issue.

The reality is that it’s the Americans who set the agenda and timeline on these discussions. Harper could have lobbied harder, Trudeau could lobby harder, Clark could lobby harder, but the reality is regardless of who is, or was, holding the reins of power in this province and/or Ottawa, we would likely still be facing these tariffs today.

It’s in the American lumber lobby’s best interests to launch these actions. An agreement needs two sides to agree and when the  softwood lumber deal expired, the Americans were in no hurry to negotiate a new one … so here we sit.

What could we have done? Well, we could have done what all the politicians say they are doing but not … actually diversifying the lumber industry and lessening our reliance on selling dimension lumber into the U.S.

Ramblings of a recovering newspaper editor
Is a coalition the path to a majority?October 15, 2019NDP leader Jagmeet Singh unleashed a bit of an election tizzy this week when he said the New Democrats would work with any other party [...]
Is a coalition the path to a majority?
Wading through the proportional representation fearmongeringAugust 1, 2018There is a lot of misinformation, fearmongering, cheap shots, and just plain lies flying around the discussion about proportional representation in British Columbia. It’s coming [...]
Wading through the proportional representation fearmongering
The Liberal voting paradoxFebruary 2, 2018BC Liberals are choosing a new leader this weekend. Ah to be a Liberal and comfortable in the paradox of voting. Led by all the [...]
The Liberal voting paradox
Party lines spoil the partyJune 29, 2017Today’s the day that we finally put an end to the political machinations that were set in motion May 9 … or is it just [...]
Party lines spoil the party
Clark got swept, but still wants to play Game 7May 31, 2017So, it’s going to be another two or three weeks until Christy Clark resigns as premier and lets John Horgan and the NDP take over. She [...]
Clark got swept, but still wants to play Game 7
What a difference eight years makeMay 26, 2017Eight years ago, when Barack Obama was the newly-minted president of the United States, we here in this country were getting more than a little [...]
What a difference eight years make
Could we be anywhere else on softwood?April 26, 2017I’m somewhat aghast and astounded that a good portion of the media and politicians in this country seem to be surprised at this week’s announcement [...]
Could we be anywhere else on softwood?
Wow, the press releases have stoppedApril 10, 2017In case you were thinking that the media was spreading a bunch of hoo-haw about the government public relations machine kicking into overdrive with announcements [...]
Wow, the press releases have stopped
Shovellin’ money off the back of a truckMarch 28, 2017It’s not often that I agree with Citizen editor Neil Godbout, but his column today on the plethora of pandering pronouncements from our politicians was [...]
Shovellin’ money off the back of a truck
More fun with government news releasesMarch 16, 2017More fun with provincial government wordsmiths. Yesterday Victoria issued an environmental assessment certificate to the Kemess Underground mine project. Nothing wrong with that. The news [...]
More fun with government news releases
Government wordsmiths need some ‘upskilling’March 15, 2017Learned a new word this morning, courtesy of the provincial government. The news release updating the province’s tech strategy contains the following sentence: “The program [...]
Government wordsmiths need some ‘upskilling’
We should have an election every yearMarch 13, 2017It’s amazing what a police investigation, in an election year, can accomplish. Global News is reporting this morning that the B.C. Liberals are about to [...]
We should have an election every year
Government’s quotable quotesMarch 8, 2017Victoria employs a small army of public relations/communications people to tell us all that is good with government. And, of course, they do not put [...]
Government’s quotable quotes
Electoral change takes courage – who has some?February 6, 2017I have to admit I was a little envious of those who got picked to serve on British Columbia’s Citizen’s Assembly on Electoral Reform. Even [...]
Electoral change takes courage – who has some?

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *